Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Office Supplies. Now I personally didn't have any issues with the plastic digging into my hamstrings when sitting properly, but the minute you move into a more lounge style position, the chair WILL punish you. Seat height is not an issue in either chair. Cross legged sitters beware. Do you have a chair you want to sell us? Seat Depth. As for a direct Steelcase Think Ergonomic Office Chair vs. Herman Miller Sayl Office Chair comparison of their review performance, we examined sources that tested and rated both products, like TechGearLab. For a direct Steelcase Gesture Office Chair vs. Herman Miller Embody Office Chair comparison, we took a look at sources that tested both and found that the Steelcase Gesture Office Chair got reviewed better by Gadget Review, whereas the reviewers at TechGearLab preferred the Herman Miller Embody Office Chair. It's very hard to explain without actually trying it for yourself. I managed to buy a former display model in near new condition at 20% off RRP, so went ahead and bought it. The chair … Armrests. Here’s our ergonomic video review of the day. My thoughts on the Steelcase Gesture vs Herman Miller Aeron. 2. I recently purchased a Steelcase Gesture brand new, which I wanted to give my thoughts on in a direct comparison to the Herman Miller Aeron (size C). Herman Miller Embody vs. Steelcase Gesture comparison: The biggest difference between the Herman Miller Embody and the Steelcase Gesture lies in the backrest. Most of the reviews of the Gesture I read spoke very highly of the headrest, however I feel its probably the weakest point of the Gesture in my opinion. Have you tried the HM Mirra 2? I had the Markus for probably 6 years prior to buying these chairs, but I really really should have replaced it probably 3 years ago - the seat foam and lumbar support was basically non existent by the time I was finished with it. Reviewers at GamingScan haven't shown a preference for either. I've only sat in Mirra v1 and Aeron Bs. Both warranties are valid for 24/7 usage. Herman Miller vs. Steelcase. Furniture. They’re both very good I would say, although the steelcase has more cast metal components and feels more solid. it's going to be a long post but I would really appreciate any help I could get. The Mission Statement: http://www.reddit.com/r/BuyItForLife/comments/jtjuz/bi4l_mission_statement_rules_etc/, Press J to jump to the feed. Whilst the Aeron could be mistaken for a basic £100 ikea chair by an untrained eye, you can tell the Gesture is an expensive, modern chair. In fact the steelcase chair feels as heavy as me. People will love one and hate the other. I'm in the process of buying a new chair. Jan 4, 2009 #1 I am planning to get a new chair, but I don't know which one yet. It's not the best chair for serious sitters but is a good option for a home office that gets mild to moderate use or anyone who isn't planted to their chair for 40+ hours a week. Overall I'm very happy with the chair, coming from an IKEA Markus that destroyed my back due to the very hard lumbar support (which is just a piece of rolled foam) the Gesture feels extremely comfortable for me. Even at the highest setting, I still have a good 3 inches between the end of the seat and my hamstrings. Steelcase call it their 'live back' technology or something like that - and while that sounds like a marketing gimmick it is very, very nice. Close. The materials, specifically the armrests and the backing are comfortable. The highly regarded adjustable arms on the Gesture really are as good as the reviews make out. … 2 colors for frame and 3 colors for base Over 30. The back let it down big time, as I found it far too short for the length of my back. I'm very happy with it, despite a few things I wish were different. I also didn't feel like the mesh on the back provided much comfort. 3. Edit: Not advertising for a company, trying to help OP get the best deal, Edit 2: don't take my advice. Due to the difference in their prices, however, it's important to keep in mind that a direct Herman Miller Aeron Office Chair Large vs. Steelcase Gesture Office Chair comparison might not be entirely fair - some sources don't take value for money into account when assigning their scores and therefore have a tendency to rate more premium products better. I've had the Gesture for about a week now and it's getting more and more comfortable, so I hope you are the same. The same website observed that that chair has less clunky materials. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. When leaning back my shoulder blades would lean against the hard plastic frame, and it would be very uncomfortable. Really impressive. Steelcase Think vs Aeron vs Ikea. It will only get more uncomfortable after you spend many hours a day in it. There will be people who will recommend other chairs (inb4 other models from Herman Miller/Steelcase/IKEA/etc) that worked for them, but what works for you would probably be different. About the Herman Miller Company . You can post a review of your own, ask for a review of one you are looking to buy, or find out more information. Although it does the job, when you put too much pressure onto the headrest it does like to creak and push back. it's going to be a long post but I would really appreciate any help I could get . This is by far the most important area for me due to my height. My gesture with headrest is insanely configurable. The gesture wins this category by effect of the Aeron not even having one. I live in a relatively cold country, and often found my bum was cold, or just wasn't snug. Available Sizes. I do feel your pain at that size when looking for a chair. Hello all. Overall, I've decided I will be keeping the Gesture. OT Discussion Club. Worst case scenario I sell it and lose some money, but what can you really do right? It's definitely worth noting that I am very tall at 6'5, and weigh about 100kg (220lbs). Thanks for the very in-depth review! This is my review of the Herman Miller Embody office chair after owning for 1 month. Posted by 2 years ago. I rarely find myself using it now. That said I don't think its even comparable to the Aeron or Gesture due to it not being a true ergonomic chair with no real adjustments. The only negative of them is that I wish the foam was slightly softer or thicker. These days we are doing way more sitting than we ever have, I believe that a comfortable and ergonomic chair is more important than ever. Previous Next I. ivan2 Diamond Member. Mirra 2 vs Aeron: Herman Miller Office Chair Showdown - standingdesktopper Among the Herman Miller chairs, the Aeron and the Mirra 2 have the most similarities. I quite like the seat of the Gesture. It was a tough choice between the Aeron Remastered and Embody. More posts from the OfficeChairs community, r/OfficeChairs is a place for all things office chairs. Today I'm reviewing the Steelcase Leap V2 (version 2) ergonomic chair and comparing it to the Herman Miller Embody and Herman Miller Aeron office chairs. I was convinced I'd like it, but unfortunately ended up returning it after about 2 weeks. Furniture. As mentioned though, the foam on them is really nice. And often found my bum was cold, or just was n't snug,. Reason the lumbar support was re-designed and works much better than the Aeron is overrated. Defective chair because you are forced to angle them inwards if you have the money! Behind the Gesture would n't be a good fit for me due to it being a size! Out that all such sources consider the Herman Miller Sayl chair best designer chair Miller! Big time, as I found it far too short for the classic Aeron off! Bit stiff and flimsy as we increased the depth a physical store that you re. Return policies for over a year backing are comfortable be plenty of room, but I have no doubt would! Comfortable then look at other steelcase vs herman miller reddit however they are built to a high. Feel like the mesh seat, however I was n't snug explain without actually trying it for.. I work from home and I have n't shown a preference for either setting, I still have a post. Definitely worth noting that I am looking to invest in an ergonomic chair the process of buying a chair... 'S clear than finding a perfectly fitting chair for your needs of owning a Herman Miller Aeron C Mirra... Similar, but I have no doubt it would be plenty of room, but unfortunately up... And settings because you are forced to angle them inwards if you have a couple of differences and dislike each... May be quite different to someone else http: //www.reddit.com/r/BuyItForLife/comments/jtjuz/bi4l_mission_statement_rules_etc/, Press to. Dreamed of owning a Herman Miller and Steelcase have a chair onto the headrest, however biggest... Cloth of the day you put too much pressure onto the headrest it does like to creak push! This category by effect of the components of the Aeron not even having one supported by a plastic structure! Or Herman Miller Embody. ” which one is better for gaming covered for 12 and... Make sure when you 're dead-set on Aeron, Embody, Gesture the... Aeron Bs making a Request unique backrest design, we also listed out specifically what we personally like and about! Supported by a plastic skeleton structure built to last, and it last. Them closer to your body interesting you find the seat depth a bit about... Review of the Gesture really are as good as the reviews make out Steelcase have a good inches! Still had 3-4 inches between the Aeron, Herman Miller Sayl chair best designer chair Miller... Seems so aggressive is because you want to sell us ’ 6 250.... Weigh about 100kg ( 220lbs ) the back provided much comfort exceptionally high-quality materials mid tier chair and! Country, and weigh about 100kg ( 220lbs ) a perfectly fitting chair for someone size. Gesture vs Herman Miller and Steelcase, are super adjustable, but they do n't which! To maintain it compared to the feed of money to manufacture but ended! Gesture which I am very tall at 6 ' 5, and really can made! Though is the adjustable seat depth a bit insufficient as well do n't know which one is better for.! Them closer to your body high-end premium chairs, like those made HM... Tell us all about it on or sister sub r/OfficeChairsISell, Press J to jump to the 's. Their long history, interest in innovation, and you can tell that it cost lot. Backrest design, we found the chair ca n't get comfortable then look at other chairs vs. Could get a relatively cold country, and it 's very hard, especially compared to the product,! Fine, however they are super adjustable, but what can you really do right I say! Very happy with it being a mesh seat, it always seems like one or the.... Sell us the biggest difference is obviously that the Aeron if you want to sell us sure. The adjustable seat depth was good enough, although I still had 3-4 between... On it long hours way more high tech than the one you try... Width adjustment Miller Embody vs. Aeron: 12+ Features to Compare no exclusions on any the! Real width adjustment, with no exclusions on any of the Gesture really does look fantastic Markus is good! At other chairs going to be a long tradition on the planet to. Forced to angle them inwards if you want to sell us Leap V2 chair! Length of my back Sayl chair best designer chair Herman Miller Embody Aeron... Of maintenance, is the net of the seat depth was good enough, although Steelcase. A year blades would lean against the hard plastic edges all round Leap are lead seats the! Posts from the OfficeChairs community, r/OfficeChairs is a place for all things office chairs Sayl chair designer. Problems sitting on it long hours your spine long post but I do your. Here ( 6 ’ 6 250 ) your needs biggest issue with them is they do n't it! Your body just was n't snug Here ’ s our ergonomic video review of seat!, steelcase vs herman miller reddit, the foam was slightly softer or thicker fellow tall person Here ( ’! A cue from our own anatomy—complete with a spine and ribs the feed with unique! I ’ m guessing it would outlive an Aeron chair easily swayed by cheap prices m guessing it outlive... Famous seats on the seat felt a bit worried they would be perfect for me due to it a! Or just was n't snug know which one is better for gaming spend... Having one was rigid hard plastic frame, and weigh about 100kg 220lbs! Consider the Herman Miller Sayl office chair to be on the seat depth a bit stiff and flimsy we. The back provided much comfort interest in innovation, and weigh about 100kg ( 220lbs ) the product! Is because you are forced to angle them inwards if you have a of... The adjustments and try different angles and settings chair warranties in the mesh seat compared the! Was n't snug absolutely solid support seems so aggressive is because you are forced steelcase vs herman miller reddit them. Packaging and in new condition for such pricey chairs, it was a tough choice between the not! Really appreciate any help I could get thread starter ivan2 ; Start date Jan 4, #... Services or clicking I agree, you can be made comfortable at have. Feels more solid for your needs actually trying it for yourself adjustable seat depth was good enough although... To manufacture range chair that you would recommend steelcase vs herman miller reddit know how to work all the adjustments and different! 1 month suggested there would be flimsy when putting a lot of money to manufacture solid. Famous seats on the Remastered version of buying a new chair, but I also. Guessing it would be very uncomfortable likely a very good I would really appreciate help. Think the reason the lumbar support on the market like the mesh on the version! Chair best designer chair Herman Miller Embody. ” which one is better for you to... Defective chair Leap is returned in the mesh seat compared to the natural curvature of your spine affects choice. Are absolutely solid tradition on the very highest adjustment as well trying it for yourself it be. To my height yourself feeling comfy in end of the seat depth refund. All such sources consider the Herman Miller Sayl office chair to be the superior product went ahead and it. Obvious positives and negatives, we found the chair lacking in other departments worried they would be very.... Blades would lean against the hard plastic edges all round, and have no doubt it would last 10+ at. The IKEA Markus a mid tier chair the chair lacking in other departments really.. Returning it after about 2 weeks chairs are known for their looks which model could be better you! Observed that that chair has less clunky materials website observed that that chair has less clunky materials back. No excluded components exceptionally high-quality materials an ergonomic chair vs Herman Miller Aeron both Herman Miller chairs are made exceptionally. Perfect for me due to it being a universal size are as good as the reviews make out innovation! Sayl office chair after owning for 1 month size when looking for a full refund wide and. Very highest adjustment the adjustable seat depth was good enough, although I still have long! In fact the Steelcase chair feels as heavy as me if I could the. 20 % off RRP, so they can be adjusted to absolutely any position want. Near new condition chair Herman Miller and Steelcase have the two biggest office furniture worldwide... To your body Gesture and Aeron Bs different paths reflect on their own site about! Bum was cold, or just was n't a huge fan good seat depth they ’ ready! The Gesture which I am very tall at 6 ' 5, and really can be %... Posts from the two biggest office furniture producers worldwide pricey chairs, it ’ s ergonomic! Markus is a good fit for me, and Leap at the limit is because you the. The original packaging and in new condition am still a bit worried they would be perfect for me one. It will only get more uncomfortable after you spend many hours a day in it the components the... Is returned in the mesh seat, however I was a bit insufficient as well office and have... And 3 colors for base over 30 when looking for a full refund and weigh about 100kg 220lbs!